Normally I open these reviews with some kind of rhetorical question about the game and then give my opinion out in pieces over the course of several paragraphs, but today's subject has put me in such a rotten mood that I can't be bothered to even entertain the idea there's anything redeemable about it. In short, Metaphor is everything I despised about Persona 5 again, now with the added insufferability of a director/writer so high on the success Sega bought him that he now thinks he's some irreplaceable paragon of talent and virtue who's beyond all reproach. Well, he's not; his latest dungheap is just another thoughtless retread of the modern Persona formula, just with even more obnoxious distracting visual effects and word bubbles in 35 different fonts constantly popping up on screen coupled with some of the worst writing I've ever seen in any medium, let alone video games. The dialog feels nothing like real conversation and entirely like one stupid teenager manning a dozen sock accounts on Reddit; every character speaks in the exact same repetitive rapid-fire cadence and pattern, and every line is overwritten to cram in as many clichéd turns of phrase and snarky quips and glib one-liners as possible in some desperate attempt to sound clever. Well, it's about as convincing as showing off your collection of expensive books with uncracked spines to prove how smart you are; unless they're willfully ignorant hero-worshippers or just have the deductive skills of a toddler, you're not fooling anyone.
Metaphor's whole morality play unfolds in the most simple, childish way possible. Good and evil are clearly defined opposites with no nuance or ambiguity whatsoever, or so we're told. All the heroes are presented as infallible selfless übermenschen who always have correct information and inevitably make the right decisions, so logically anyone in their way must be the complete opposite. We certainly never see any evidence to the contrary; all the villains do is commit heinous acts without any hesitation and love every second of it. They also proudly spell out their ethos to the player in plain, unambiguous language just to make sure there's absolutely no doubt in your mind that they're completely irredeemable. That's because none of Katsura Hashino's antagonists have any nuance or humanity whatsoever, they're just straw men for him and other armchair revolutionaries to point at and say "Sure I never do anything that isn't cowardly, manipulative or self-serving, but I'm not as bad as THESE guys so therefore I'm a good person, now worship me and destroy anyone who doesn't!". Likewise, there isn't a single scene in the game that showcases any genuine wisdom, insight or plan of action regarding the social topics it's spotlighting, just smug speechifying. Just like Persona 5, no thought is ever spared for how violence and vengeance just beget more of the same, or how innocent people suffer most when giant egos clash, or that there's any degrees of severity between crimes and criminals, or how taking one problematic person out of the equation doesn't solve systemic problems and prejudices; nope, everyone instantly joins hands to sing Kumbaya and bow to our heroes in reverence after they punch the latest smirky cardboard cutout baddie around a bit and belt out smarmy one-liners all the while they're doing it. Lameass Rob Liefeld messiah fantasy bullshit at its worst.
Nothing in Metaphor qualifies as storytelling, or even as having a writing process behind it. It's just Hashino transcribing all the loaded arguments and witty banter and juvenile power fantasies going through his own head every minute of every day so he can show off how smart and pious he thinks he is and how shallow, stupid and immoral he thinks everyone else is. Forget being insulting, he's utterly contemptful of his audience's intelligence; rather than letting you intuit anything through subtext or even context, the game constantly shows you a thing, then a character explains the thing to you in simple words, then another character (or two, or three) has to tell it to you again five seconds later just to make sure you get it. Literally every dialog scene goes exactly like this:
Game shows the player a map
DIPSHIT FAIRY: This is a map! Boy it's a well made map! You know what a map is, right Main Character?
OTHER GUY: This map will show us to our destination!
YET ANOTHER GUY: Our destination is here! Click the location on the map to lead us there, Main Character
This is an M-rated video game, not Dora the Explorer. No actually I take that back; at least the characters on Dora act like real people and not charismaless Beetlejuices. This is a Sonichu comic with a budget. There, that's a better analogy.
People like Hashino are completely self-serving. They have never once led by example and never will. They honestly believe they're the very first to come up with all these empty platitudes about race relations and social reform, expecting their fans to do all the thinking and hard work required to make them a reality while they get rich and famous making shitty derivative art about it once every decade. Don't think any of his fanboys/enablers will ever practice his preaching either; all they ever do is emulate him and become more reality-detached idea guys who think there's no difference between posturing about a thing on the internet (or in a video game) and actually doing it. They only care about being perceived as intelligent, empathetic and just people to collect social currency and followers, not about doing anything that will benefit anyone other than themselves. They've corrupted Persona - once a brilliant and poignant franchise about being true to yourself and finding value in your life, relationships and humanity despite their inherent flaws - into a celebration of their own narcissism and delusional grandeur. The fact that Sega has the gall to charge you another $70 for this shit is just shameless too, especially when you can log onto any social media platform and get your fill of empty preening for free.
Oh and you can spare the lame fallacy about how I just hate this game because it's "woke"; I'm about as left-wing as you can get. I've also consumed plenty of media that espouses leftist views and given many of them positive appraisals, because they did so in an intelligent, empathetic and sincere way; you can find many examples on this very website if you actually bother to look instead of just cherry-picking enough out-of-context quotes to whip up a lynch mob on Tumblr. I just hate when corporate toadies like Hashino oversimplify the current political climate and coat it in a thin veneer of art so they can score brownie points with idiots who think virtue is measured in arbitrary stat bars and social media Likes, and not in giving a shit about anything beside themselves. Hell, Hashino doesn't even believe in the 'movement' he's selling you; it's all just part of his self-serving scheme to build a bigger pre-installed audience for his next game and reap more praise for himself and profits for the rich conservatives that hold Sega stock (who, surprise, don't believe in it either) so he can keep his job an overpaid, overpraised hack. Any positive outreach or instances of vicious harassment his works inspire are completely incidental to his own self-dealing, and there's about 500,000 times more of one than the other (I'll give you a hint: the good one ain't winning). So instead of spending $70 to live out someone else's vapid superhero fantasy, why not donate some of that money to MSF instead. Or buy something made by a talented indie dev or musician or artist who could probably really use even a tiny fraction of the revenue this garbage will generate. Or hell, even drop a few dollars in a random person's Ko-Fi with no expectation of anything back. Any legitimate act of charity, no matter how small, is infinitely more noble than being superficially virtuous to score brownie points with other do-nothing pretenders...
Developer: Atlus Studio Zero
Publisher: Sega
Released: 2024
Platforms: PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, PC, XBox Series
Note to publishers: If you want to give the impression that your game's really 'progressive' and 'woke' and avoid attracting the worst people on the planet to it, maybe don't have it describe an idealized utopia using phrases that sound uncomfortably similar to fascist slogans; like, say, "one united tribe". Or have a guy whose previous games contain homophobic and transphobic prejudice he's never apologized for deliver your big important message about unity, tolerance and caring for others...